Breaking the Chains of Tonality: Atonality and the Second Viennese School

The Second Viennese School, led by Arnold Schoenberg and his pupils Alban Berg and Anton Webern, represents one of the most significant revolutions in Western music history: the development of atonality. Arising from the 'crisis of tonality' in the late Romantic era, where extreme chromaticism had weakened the function of a central key, Schoenberg proposed the 'emancipation of the dissonance,' creating music that lacked a tonal center. This began with a period of 'free atonality' (e.g., *Pierrot Lunaire*), an intuitive and highly expressive style that broke from the past but lacked a large-scale organizing principle. To solve this structural problem, Schoenberg developed the twelve-tone technique (or serialism), a systematic method for organizing the twelve pitches of the chromatic scale into a fixed order called a 'tone row.' This row, along with its transformations (inversion, retrograde, retrograde inversion), served as the genetic blueprint for a composition, ensuring no single pitch could dominate. While Schoenberg established the system, his pupils applied it in unique ways. Alban Berg integrated the technique with a Romantic expressive sensibility, creating lyrical and dramatic works like the Violin Concerto that connect the new language with the past. In contrast, Anton Webern took a more radical, abstract approach, crafting brief, sparse, and meticulously organized pieces that would profoundly influence the avant-garde composers who followed.

1. Introduction: The Crisis of Tonality

By the turn of the 20th century, the Western classical music tradition stood at a precipice. The system of tonality—the hierarchical organization of pitches around a central key or 'tonic' that had governed music since the Baroque era—was being stretched to its breaking point. Composers of the late Romantic period, such as Richard Wagner in his opera Tristan und Isolde, used extreme chromaticism and delayed resolutions to create a sense of perpetual longing and tension. This 'crisis of tonality' created a question: if all twelve notes of the chromatic scale are used with increasing frequency and freedom, does a central key even matter anymore? It was into this environment that the Second Viennese School emerged, a group of composers led by Arnold Schoenberg and his two most prominent pupils, Alban Berg and Anton Webern, who would provide a revolutionary answer: No.

2. From Tonality to Free Atonality

Atonality, in its simplest definition, is music that lacks a tonal center or key. There is no 'home' note to return to; the traditional hierarchy of pitches is dissolved. Schoenberg described this move not as a destruction of old rules, but as the "emancipation of the dissonance." In tonal music, dissonances (unstable-sounding combinations of notes) demand resolution to consonances (stable-sounding combinations). In atonal music, dissonance is freed from this obligation; it can exist as a stable, independent entity, allowing for a vastly expanded harmonic and expressive palette.

Schoenberg's journey into atonality was gradual. His early work, like the string sextet Verklärte Nacht (1899), is deeply rooted in the lush, chromatic language of late Romanticism. However, by 1908, with his String Quartet No. 2, he made a decisive break. The final movement famously has no key signature, and a soprano soloist enters singing the words, "Ich fühle luft von anderem planeten" ("I feel the air of another planet"), a clear metaphor for his entry into a new musical world.

This initial phase is now known as "free atonality." In this period, composers abandoned key signatures and traditional harmony, but had not yet developed a new system to replace it. Composition was guided by intuition, text (in vocal music), and the desire to avoid any gestures that might imply a key. A quintessential example is Schoenberg's _Pierrot Lunaire_ (1912), a song cycle for a female vocalist and chamber ensemble. The music is unsettling and expressionistic, perfectly matching the macabre poetry. It also features the innovative vocal technique of _Sprechstimme_ ('speech-song'), where the vocalist approximates pitches in a declamatory, speech-like rhythm, further distancing the music from traditional melody.

3. Systematizing Chaos: The Twelve-Tone Technique (Serialism)

While free atonality was expressively powerful, it posed a structural problem. Without the gravitational pull of a tonic and the architectural forms it supported (like sonata form), how could a composer create large-scale, purely instrumental works that felt coherent? Schoenberg felt this 'chaos' needed a new underlying logic. His solution, developed in the early 1920s, was the twelve-tone technique, also known as dodecaphony or serialism.

This method provided a systematic way to ensure all twelve chromatic pitches are treated equally. The basic principles are:

1. The Tone Row (or Series): The composer creates a specific ordering of all twelve pitches of the chromatic scale. This row serves as the foundational melodic and harmonic material for the entire composition.
2. No Repetition: Within the row, no pitch may be repeated until all other eleven have been sounded. This rigorously prevents any single note from asserting dominance and becoming a tonic.
3. Transformations: To create variety, the row can be manipulated in four primary forms:

Prime (P): The original version of the row. Inversion (I): The melodic intervals of the row are inverted (e.g., a rising third becomes a falling third). Retrograde (R): The row is played backward. Retrograde Inversion (RI): The inverted row is played backward.

All four of these forms can also be transposed to start on any of the twelve chromatic pitches. This system gave Schoenberg a vast but logically controlled set of materials to build his compositions. His Piano Suite, Op. 25 is one of the earliest and clearest examples of this technique in practice.

4. The Disciples: Berg's Romanticism and Webern's Radicalism

Schoenberg's pupils, Berg and Webern, adopted the twelve-tone technique but applied it in highly personal and distinct ways.

Alban Berg is often seen as the most approachable and 'Romantic' of the three. He masterfully blended Schoenberg's innovations with the lyricism and dramatic gesture of the past. Berg's use of the tone row was often flexible, and he would design rows that contained tonal-sounding fragments, such as thirds or triads, creating a link to the music of the past. His opera _Wozzeck_ is a masterpiece of free atonality, using traditional forms (sonata, fugue, passacaglia) to structure each scene with devastating dramatic effect. His later Violin Concerto (1935) uses a tone row that includes G, D, A, and E, allowing him to embed the open strings of the violin directly into the series. The work even quotes a Bach chorale, seamlessly integrating it into the twelve-tone texture in a poignant tribute to Manon Gropius, the daughter of Alma Mahler.

Anton Webern, in contrast, took a more radical and abstract path. He is the composer of extreme concentration and brevity; some of his pieces last less than a minute. For Webern, the tone row was an object of absolute purity. He applied serialist principles with crystalline rigor, often creating intricate palindromic structures. His music is frequently described as 'pointillistic', constructed from tiny fragments of sound, silence, and distinct instrumental timbres. He was a pioneer of _Klangfarbenmelodie_ ('tone-color melody'), where a melodic line is fractured and distributed among several different instruments. A work like his Symphony, Op. 21 (1928) exemplifies this approach: it is sparse, symmetrical, and every single note feels meticulously placed within a complex web of relationships. Webern's radical organization of pitch, rhythm, and timbre would become profoundly influential on the composers of the post-WWII avant-garde.

Browse public study notes